Your home for intelligent conversation on the web
The Living Room Me and society Don't call me stupid
THINQon is a platform for a more intelligent web. It aims to replace the ruling paradigm of the web – that of sharing and gathering information – with a sharing and achieving of understanding. Instead of the Q&A model it offers an experience. A platform for discovery of ideas, people, and yourself.     Continue >
Don't call me stupid
A friend of mine, who does not know me for a very long time, has recently told me something I said was stupid. I found this to be quite funny, but she immediately was taken aback as if scared by not having thought enough about what she said and afraid of having offended me, which she was not at all the case. A discussion obviously quickly followed, in what contexts can one say to someone they are speaking with that what they have said is stupid? Thinking about it, I realized that I often call other people stupid, in their absence, but that I don't often, if ever, tell them to their face that what they are saying is stupid, with the exception of family members, whom I have no problem calling stupid. Is stupid still such a strong expression? does it require a really intimate relation with someone to be used? why is this the case?
Please let me know what you think, even if this is a stupid question. 
I've found that there are some seemingly innocuous words that actually carry a lot of bite. I never really thought about 'stupid' being one of them, but I see how it can fall under that category.

Stupid is a very simple word, it is one we learned very early in childhood, so when it's used it sounds and feels slightly silly, almost innocent. It is used matter-of-factly and usually without much thought. If something is stupid, its stupidness is rarely justified, it is just a fact that doesn't merit further discussion. And I guess with that comes a certain degree of unintentional superiority.

Another word I find very similar to stupid is 'jerk.' Jerk hits hard when it used. If I'm ever called a jerk I stop in my tracks and self-evaluate.

But a lot of this obviously comes down to tone and familiarity. Words are just endlessly funny because definitions change by delivery.

 For instance, the following 7 word sentence can have 7 different meanings depending on which words you stress:
"I never said she stole my money."
I must admit I frequently call people stupid, to their face, but only good friends of mine. If they do something stupid, or say something stupid, I call them on it.
While calling someone a jerk, Clark, is a more general comment on someone's character, stupid is local. 2+2=4 stupid, not 5. So the person made a mistake. It is a local mistake and doesn't say much about them generally. I usually do at least 10 stupid things a day. I get annoyed at myself a bit, call myself stupid, and move on (hopefully they are not such serious mistakes).

Doug, I think the problem is that people don't accept it as local, they hear it as a judgment on their whole being. You calling me stupid? Especially if people respect you they can be offended by your judgment of them as stupid. They don't understand it is not a judgment of them but a local one on a very simple matter.
For example, students say the stupidest things, but if anybody would call them on it they would feel attacked. More so because they know what they meant to say and what they meant to say was very smart. It wasn't what came out, but if you say something about what came out, well, they feel you are judging what they meant to say, and by proxy, them. (Similarly, I once told a woman I thought she didn't look good in a certain picture of hers. That was a mistake. It didn't help if I thought she looked great in 20 other ones, nope.)

I think the moment someone knows you better and is a friend, they feel you can talk more locally, more to specific points, while someone you don't know well, judging any bit of them is a more general judgment, they feel.

Having said all that, once, after a while of not talking to close friends, when a certain friend of mine replied to something I said - Baloney! I was a bit shocked. It's stupid, but one is simply not used to it in the world and then when it comes it is shocking.


Clark, great last line.
This is why I often say instead, THAT was stupid. Rather than the person being stupid. Seems to wok for me. :)
Join the Community
Full Name:
Your Email:
New Password:
I Am:
By registering at THINQon.com, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Discussion info
Latest Post: February 23, 2010 at 3:56 AM
Number of posts: 4
Spans 250 days

  
Searching
No results found.